Haunted Journeys

Pettibone Tavern

Pettibone Tavern

Weatogue, Connecticut
06089 USA

Add to Favorites

Our Badges


Weatogue, CT is home to one of the most haunted eateries in the nation, Pettibone Tavern (Formerly known as Abigail's Grille and Wine Bar). Come explore its offerings with Haunted Journeys. 

The History

This tavern was built by Jonathon Pettibone, Jr. to serve as a stagecoach stop in 1780, serving the Boston to Albany Turnpike. This was during the havoc of the American Revolution. After the war, the Pettibone Tavern remained a gathering spot for the growing community and a meeting spot for discussing strategy and plans for the Revolution. George Washington, Ethan Allena, and John Adams are just a few of the notables who stayed at the tavern.

On the fringe of the frontier, it was burned to the ground by Indians in 1800. You can still view the charred remains of the hand-hewn oak timbers that supported the original tavern in the basement. The tavern re-opened in 1803.

A good tavern always has a good story, and this one is no exception. Mrs. Abigail Pettibone was the wife of a whaling captain who was gone for long stretches. Needless to say, Abigail supposedly sought comfort in the arms of another man. One time, Captain Pettibone unexpectedly came home early, caught his wife and her lover. In his rage, he immediately killed both with an ax. They say if you look closely at what is supposed to be a portrait of young Abigail with her mother that hangs in the tavern, you can see her likeness was once cut from the canvas. This all sounds like the perfect tale that is followed by haunts, and it does!

Through the years, the tavern has served as a private residence as well. In 2008, the restaurant was purchased by the current owners and after renovations re-opened as Abigail’s Grille and Wine Bar. Following another (yes) fire in 2008, it was sold to the new owner. Today it bears the name it had for almost two centuries, recognizing the original inhabitant, Pettibone Tavern!

The Hauntings

Tragedy and wars are the fundamentals of a good haunted story. This tavern is an absolute hotbed for paranormal activity. Abigail's phantom is said to still roam the tavern. Her ghostly apparition has been repeatedly seen by patrons and employees over the years. Others have reported feeling a chill when the pass the ladies' room on the second floor.

There are other claims of a child ghost. According to various sources, having been seen by many of the guests and staff. The staff has reported hearing voices, seeing candles re-light themselves and furniture that moves on its own. Many have heard disembodied voices calling out the names of the staff.

More Reads...

Spooky Trails and Tall Tales Connecticut: Hiking the State's Legends, Hauntings, and History Paperback – September 1, 2019 by Stephen Gencarella (Author)     Connecticut Ghost Stories and Legends (Haunted America) by [Thomas D'Agostino, Arlene Nicholson]     Haunted Connecticut: Ghosts and Strange Phenomena of the Constitution State (Haunted Series) by [Cheri Farnsworth]


Understand This:

This property, as part of our network, has been added for they may have history, validation, or folk tales of having spirited activities. Please take caution in approaching and visiting these locations, since courtesy, respect, and caution should be a top priority in every Haunted Investigator's style. Also do realize, some of these places may have permanently closed, changed ownership and/or names, or just are not available for your visits. Please respect this.

We are not responsible for the accuracy of the information provided on this listing, but offer it as a first step in finding your next haunted travel destination. Please do confirm with the property before making any plans to visit. If you visit, tour, or investigate this property (or any of our properties), we are not responsible or held liable for any outcomes, lack of evidence, or injuries associated with your travels. This is only for entertainment purposes, and information provided is only as found in public domains (or as offered by the associated contributor (as a claimed property).

For more information, please read our TERMS OF SERVICE (linked below).

Please select from the tags below to see more like this listing!

Date added: Jan/24/2017 | Last time updated: May/22/2020

Don't See Your Business or Favorite Haunt Listed?

    facebook instagram pinterest tumblr twitter

We participate in several affiliate programs, including the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. All of our affiliate programs are intended to provide a means for us to earn small fees by offering respected, relevant and useful products to our readers. These efforts will not be an extra cost to you and are paid directly by the advertiser as commission. Thank you for providing the opportunity to offer these products and services to you, while helping us to sustain our content delivery efforts on this website.

Hello! Please Log In